Why Face Questions When Propaganda Works?

Why Face Questions When Propaganda Works?

“Every story is good until another is heard"

This French proverb is a timely reminder that "the truth" is rarely as tidy as the initial press briefing makes it look. A version of events that seems airtight in the morning headlines can easily unravel by prime-time once a dissenting voice or an inconvenient fact enters the record.

Nowhere is this dynamic more evident than in the evolving discourse around two high-profile scandals, the sandpaper controversy in cricket and the vote theft allegations dominating the Indian political landscape, where rival camps have turned competing versions of reality into the fine statecraft of "tu-tu, main-main," leaving the public stuck picking sides in a perpetual state of confusion.

"I'm happy to take all your questions about sandpaper, ball-tampering, change rooms, international cricket, whether my wife and I did have a spat out the front. Whatever you want, hit me." Thus spoke Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins at a rare, no-holds-barred press conference, addressing fresh 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering accusations from Usman Khawaja's book alongside tabloid chatter about a recent video with his wife.

In a move that practically qualifies as an extreme sport in modern public life, Cummins called the briefing himself and fielded questions for over an hour without hiding behind a pre-approved press release. He maintained he had no knowledge of sandpaper entering the field, flatly calling Khawaja's version wrong, yet welcomed any fresh investigation to finally bury the ghost of 2018. Credit goes to Cummins for willingly stepping into the line of fire, and equal credit to Khawaja for risking dressing-room harmony to put his own version of events on the record.

Hop a few thousand miles north to the Indian political landscape, however, and that brand of unscripted accountability suddenly vanishes into thin air. When confronted with the opposition's "vote theft" allegations, the ruling establishment seems allergic to the Cummins playbook. Rather than facing the microphones or inviting an inquiry, the leadership's preferred counter-strategy relies on the tried-and-tested art of political deflection, swiftly branding the opposition as "anti-national" agents working at the behest of foreign powers to derail Indian democracy.

On the flip side, the Congress, the main opposition party leading the charge, displaying a Khawaja-like courage to tell the world how Indian democracy is being subverted, has shown an uncanny talent for scoring own goals. By hosting the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad as part of its global outreach and allowing foreign speakers on the dais to chant slogans like "Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod," the party has essentially gift-wrapped a potent talking point for the RSS and the BJP. Claims that shadowy foreign forces are conspiring to halt India's rise usually sound like standard campaign rhetoric, yet they have suddenly acquired a convenient new context. Perhaps unwittingly, the Congress has ended up giving the ruling establishment's favorite conspiracy theory a very real, contemporary political face.

Of course, the Congress has every right to mingle with global political parties and ideological movements; international dialogue is hardly a monopoly reserved for the government. Yet, what was billed as a high-minded forum for progressive politics has swiftly morphed into a textbook flashpoint over foreign meddling in domestic affairs. In the process, the opposition has handed the ruling party a golden escape hatch, allowing it to dodge any sincere reckoning over the vote theft allegations while clinging tightly to the familiar life raft of its "anti-national" narrative.

The opposition is sharp enough to grasp the basic paradox at play: the ruling establishment has zero appetite for settling scores through that old-fashioned democratic ritual known as public debate. Why risk defending a track record or engaging with tough questions when it is far easier to deploy a well-oiled propaganda machine? Armed with historical myths, manufactured distractions, emotional anxieties, and the occasional creative stretch of the truth, the establishment treats open deliberation not as the lifeblood of democracy, but as an inconvenience to be drowned out by spin. After all, why bother with messy debates when grand narratives do the heavy lifting so effortlessly?

Yet, even if the ruling leadership refuses to step into a direct debate ring with the opposition, it could still borrow a page from the Australian captain's playbook and simply answer the specific questions on the table. If the supreme leader can regularly command the nation's airwaves for “Mann Ki Baat”, a one-way monologue covering everything from exam stress to local trivia, surely, he can pull off a "Pat Cummins" moment and take a few unscripted questions to put the vote theft controversy to rest.

This persistent evasion points toward a bizarre, dystopian future. At a time when Indian democracy faces its sternest test amid grave allegations of vote theft, the ruling establishment responds with the irony of staging "Save Democracy" street stunts, while both the government and the Election Commission lean heavily on spin rather than substance to dodge tough answers. The old adage, "When thieves fall out, honest men come by their own," rings painfully hollow today. In a climate where propaganda is treated as the only acceptable reply, honest voices and whistleblowers are forced into the shadows, paralyzed by the fear of being branded "anti-national" the moment they speak up.

In the end, that old French proverb holds true: every story sounds convincing until another one enters the room, which is precisely why the ruling establishment prefers to keep the doors locked and the microphones one-sided. Why risk an unscripted, Pat Cummins-style press conference where inconvenient truths might slip through, when a well-rehearsed monologue keeps the crowd cheering?

After all, in the grand theater of Indian political spin, the supreme leader seems to operate on a timeless Bollywood philosophy borrowed from Deewaar: "Mere paas propaganda hai." Until the script changes, citizens will have to settle for tu-tu, main-main, and wait endlessly for the other side of the story to be heard.

Comments (…)

Leave a Comment

0/1000
Loading comments…

Related News

Morals Exist Only To Be Preached To Others

Morals Exist Only To Be Preached To Others

Diplomatic praise at a premium

Diplomatic praise at a premium

Pappu Can Set The Narrative, Saala?

Pappu Can Set The Narrative, Saala?

Ramayana: Soul Lost in Pixels

Ramayana: Soul Lost in Pixels

An Invincible Hero's, A Flawed Script?

An Invincible Hero's, A Flawed Script?

Ramayana: A Glossy, Over-Budget Computer Glitch

Ramayana: A Glossy, Over-Budget Computer Glitch

AP Polls: An Uncontested Model Of Democracy?

AP Polls: An Uncontested Model Of Democracy?

'Save Democracy': A Ruse As A Firewall?

'Save Democracy': A Ruse As A Firewall?

Has The BJP's Invincibility Shield Finally Cracked?

Has The BJP's Invincibility Shield Finally Cracked?

AP Local Body Polls: Game Over At Nomination

AP Local Body Polls: Game Over At Nomination

Loud Protests, Hidden Pockets?

Loud Protests, Hidden Pockets?

Rahul-Priyanka’s Street Politics Play

Rahul-Priyanka’s Street Politics Play

25 Years of Seva: Action or Slogans?

25 Years of Seva: Action or Slogans?

Nana Patekar: From Actor to Rural Reformer

Nana Patekar: From Actor to Rural Reformer

Flydubai Episode: Statecraft or Manufactured Consent?

Flydubai Episode: Statecraft or Manufactured Consent?

Captain Machchhar: Courage vs Noise

Captain Machchhar: Courage vs Noise

Deepfakes: The New Political Weapon

Deepfakes: The New Political Weapon

UPI Transactions: There Is Nothing Called 'Free Lunch'

UPI Transactions: There Is Nothing Called 'Free Lunch'